The Deodorant Experiment

I lost my deodorant.

I had already been cutting back, because there are significant amounts of research being done to try and draw a link between use of products with parabens and aluminum on the armpits and risk of developing breast cancer. While there is no conclusive evidence that such a link exists, the idea that people are questioning it makes me slightly uncomfortable. On top of that, I haven’t really found a good deodorant/antiperspirant…. ever? So the chance to try to make something myself at home for at least as cheap as the “traditional” brands, and at cheaper than the “natural” brands seemed like as good a reason as any to jump in. Also, the deodorant that caught my attention is made completely from things that are already in my kitchen.

Plus, I lost my deodorant.

I just used it the other day, which may have been last monday when my husband was last here….but i have looked for it every day and I have no idea where it evaporated too.

Moving on, this post from Crunchy Betty about deodorant and this post from Kitchen Stewardship about taking baby steps toward switching to natural deodorant were my inspiration. I liked some of these recipes for homemade natural deodorant but i don’t have the resources right now for the fancy stuff :

So here’s what I did:

  1. Mix 1/4C baking soda and 1/4C corn starch with a fork.
  2. Add in one TBS at a time of organic virgin coconut oil. Cream the oil into the powders until you get a creamy consistency.
  3. deo fluff

    It's fluffy.

  4. Add a few drops of essential oil. I don’t have an impressive essential oil stash, so I put in tea tree oil. You could add in any essential oils you like – I’m thinking about adding lemon and lavender to the next batch, if I ever run out of this one.
  5. Clean out an old deodorant container, if you want to be able to apply it in the “traditional” deodorant way. Since I lost my deodorant, I couldn’t use a girly-style container. Luckily, I found an old container lying on my husband’s side of the bed that he forgot when he went back to work. I boiled it and scrubbed the inside of the container with an old toothbrush to remove the old deodorant residue. Man, did it stink like a chemical factory D:
  6. deo container rinsed

    Three simple parts.


    inside the deodorant container

    Nice and clean inside.

  7. Use your fork to pack the deodorant mix into the container. I had a little trouble with this, but I found that as the container warmed up to my hand temperature, the oil would warm up a bit and slide further down.
  8. first pack of deodorant

    First scoop into the container


    packed down deodorant

    Almost fully packed.


    I made too much to fit in the container, and my attempts to wipe the excess oil off only made it melt out all over the place.

    The mixture was on the mushy side at this point, but I took a little bit on my finger and rubbed it in under my arm. The oil soaked in almost immediately, but the grainy texture seemed a little bit weird. My armpits itched a little bit overnight, but not much of a big deal.

    I left the deodorant out on the counter overnight to set, but it didnt really look any different this morning. I rubbed some more in under my arms after my post-work out shower, capped it, and stuck it in the fridge before work.

    refrigerated deo

    Firmed up pretty awesomely, with an awesome rugged texture.

    It showed great improvement, it was firm and deodorant-y looking. And I rubbed my finger on the top to smooth out the rugged areas. Then I rubbed it under my arms, and it felt pretty good. Like “real” deodorant.

    smoothe deo

    I put this on with a black cap-sleeve shirt on, and the thing I hated most about “regular” deodorant – the white rings under the arms! – they didnt appear all night. The story might go differently over the course of a day, but I’m dubious.

    The weird part is my underarms feel kind of grainy, but only to the touch. I was worried it would feel like sandpaper rubbing against my skin, but it’s not noticeable at all. I reapplied after taking a shower tonight, but mostly because I just really like the feel of it. The graininess is a little bit weird, and I feel a little bit itchy, but i didnt smell nasty pit funk on myself all day – a nice change after a full week without being able to find deodorant.

    I would love to get a hold of one of those containers for the creamy type “regular” deodorant – it has the dial-up plunger, plus a cap on top with little holes in it. Each turn of the dial pushes one “click” of cream up through the holes, which you spread on using the rounded top. The consistency I got when I mixed this reminded me of that immediately.


8 Responses to “The Deodorant Experiment”

  1. This is a great idea, and a sure fire way to save some money too I’m sure!

    @Amy: correct, the smell comes from bacteria, so what does anti-fungal have to do with it?

    • thanks, be sure to click through and take a look at the articles i got the idea from! i’m not sure whether it would work the same for a male – what with the hormones and the armpit hair, but if you try it out let me know! otherwise, i plan to try it out on my husband in March

    • Thanks for the correction!! Tea tree is also anti-bacterial and anti-microbial. Sorry for the confusion!

  2. I’m not sure I’m willing to go THAT far, but I do order a natural deodorant. I have been using natural for about three years now, every since my Dr told me that one of his patients had breast pain with a particular deodorant.

    Daddy might have one of those containers you covet, I will save it once he empties it and send it along.

    • its really not that far when you think about it! and then you dont have mysterious -ates and -ides in your pits, since you put everything in it yourself. if you have a container that would be awesome :D

  3. Great idea, but re. itchiness, how much tea tree oil did you put in? Tea tree is a pretty strong oil and under your arms there is delecate skin. However saying that, tea tree is a great anti-fungal which is ideal in a deodorant because underarm odour is usually a result of the bacteria enjoying the damp environment. Unless you have a reaction to the other ingredients, maybe reduce the dose of the tea tree.

    • thanks for the advice, i only put in a miniscule amount though – maybe 3-4 drops for the entire mix. i think the itching came from having just shaved a few hours earlier!

  4. Trackbacks

Leave a Reply